FUMARE
Law, culture, and Catholicism...up in smoke!
Friday, July 31, 2009
The Wanderer Unmasks Monaghan, Ave Maria
Fumed by Petronius at 4:07 PM. |
Thursday, July 30, 2009
Girl with Half a Brain Lives a Normal Life

I don't know why, but when I read this headline, I thought of Advocatus Militaris and imagined that he would have an insightful editorial comment.
Fumed by Columcille at 10:30 AM. |
Monday, July 27, 2009
Home Buying Today
Fumed by Casimir Pulaski at 10:45 PM. |
Just In Case Something Happens On Your Summer Trip
Fumed by Advocatus Militaris at 9:18 PM. |
Thursday, July 23, 2009
Henry Louis Gates Jr. is a RACIST (And So Too Is Obama)

In a national press conference Barak Obama called Sgt. James Crowley "stupid" for arresting Henry Louis Gates, Jr. for disorderly conduct in an incident where the Harvard victimologist agressively played the race card against a police officer who was dutifully protecting Gates home.
Fumed by Columcille at 9:10 AM. |
Wednesday, July 22, 2009
A Real First LADY
No... not that one.I don't see U.S. first lady as a fashion star, or for that matter, do I think she has much positive public presence. She seems irritated and angry most of the time.
On the other hand, I've sort of developed a bit of a mini-crush on Russian first lady Svetlana Medvedeva. She's married, I know, but there's a lot to admire in this woman *ahem* lady. She's pro-life, pro-family, anti-abortion, pretty, and publicly religious -- promoting the roles of tradition and culture. In a few paragraphs of a recent news article, you get the snapshot:

Week Against Abortions
In addition to promoting strong families in the Russian tradition, Medvedeva said, today’s holiday is intended to teach young people about the importance of marriage and children and to oppose abortion. Indeed, when asked about the specific measures this holiday involved, she pointed to plans for a “Week against Abortions” beginning tomorrow.
Traditional Family
Many people, the Russian first lady said, now talk about “the collapse of the traditional family” as some kind of “natural” trend. But she argued that one should oppose that trend with all the resources available. On the one hand, she said, when women enjoy equal rights, “the importance of the family is only growing.”
State Power Cannot Force People to Change -- Fight the Negative Forces
And on the other, “even if it is not so simple to stop negative tendencies, this does not mean that one should do nothing,” a task that requires the combined efforts of state and church because “the efforts of the state alone are insufficient. No one can force people to change if they themselves do not want to.
Undoing Marxist Communism By Reinvigorating Tradition
In order to achieve that end, Medvedeva said, the role of Russian traditions is critical. Many of the country’s current problems are the result of “the break with traditions which took place in the last century. And what is a tradition? This is the living experience of previous generations, our parents, grandparents and great grandparents.”
And about that Socialism thing... here's a different spin:
and don't miss Cow Invasion Petrifies Russian Town: Roving Bovines Prove Udderly Unruly
Fumed by Casimir Pulaski at 9:45 PM. |
Obama Needs to Read "Caritas in Veritate"

Real Clear Politics has a video posted of Obama on the Today Show being asked about placing a sur-tax on the rich to pay for universal socialized health care. The clip has a revealing exchange:
Fumed by Columcille at 10:10 AM. |
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
Sports! Sports! Sports! Sports!

Fumed by Boko Fittleworth at 8:39 PM. |
Monday, July 20, 2009
FUMARE FIRED FESSIO
FUMARE didn't like Fr. Fessio, and we put the administrative hit on him. Monaghan, in his pesky pride, is just trying to take credit for it by craftily blaming the University Chairman.
You've heard it before, nothing bad happens without being caused by FUMARE. This time, it was the AMU board that claims to have gotten rid of Fessio. Last time, Monaghan did it himself. It doesn't matter to FUMARE who did the dirty work, as long as the contracts get done.
American Papist got it wrong (and they should know better because it is part of the destructive force of bloging). AveWatch got it wrong, too -- and we all know that AveWatch is the secret base camp of academic terrorism.
Well, FUMARE is tired of all the PR that shifts blame onto meaningless factors like Monaghan or Boards, or management, and is taking it on the chin for the team! We are team players!!!
Even two years ago, the seeds of this great lie were planted, when Whispers in the Loggia reported that a meeting between Fessio and Monaghan resulted in Fessio being fired.
There's no telling how much money AMU had to pay Fessio to blame them instead of FUMARE, but it's surely part of the settlement between them.
All these crooked blogs are craftily shifting blame onto Monaghan, when in fact, FUMARE FIRED him. U.S. News and World Reports realizes it. That's why the law school has such a low rank. Somebody needs to clue Brian Leiter in, though.
Fumed by Casimir Pulaski at 8:23 PM. |
FESSIO FIRED AGAIN
UPDATE: The text of Fr. Fessio's email explaining the situation may be found at AveWatch here.
Fumed by Advocatus Militaris at 6:11 PM. |
Saturday, July 18, 2009
Fumare Exclusive: An Interview with Richard Armittage
Fumed by Petronius at 4:21 PM. |
Thursday, July 16, 2009
Lawsuit News
Also, a fumare poll that I am too lazy to create, let alone imbed:
There are three types of people:
1) Those who initiate purges.
2) Those who survive purges.
3) Those who get purged.
T$M and Joseph Stalin are examples of the first type. Jim Sonne and some jagoff Russki whose name I can't be bothered up to look are examples of the second type.
Query: Of which type is Mr.Dobranski an example (and don't say "three")?
Fumed by Boko Fittleworth at 9:11 PM. |
Is Dr. David Schindler a Key Influence in Caritas in Veritate?

As was reading through the Encyclical I was struck by the echoes of the work of Dr. David L. Schindler in the text.
At first reading it may not seem to be all that critical of an insight that the pope is making, but on further reflection, the pope is making a significant step in the development of the social doctrine.
The "new" is this idea of the "logic of the unconditional gift", "gratuitousness" as a third way.
Compare what Benedict is saying about this (in sections III and IV) to David L. Schindler, especially in the book "Wealth, Poverty and Human Destiny" - in his chapter "'Homelessness' and Market Liberalism" he has a whole section on "Towards an Economy of Gift and Gratitude." This is the longest essay in the book and the most intellectually satisfying for its depth and realism in marshaling a critique of Market Liberalism. This idea of the "logic of unconditional gift" is a very deep anthropological argument that is ground shaking because (like the Theology of the Body) it is a foundational perspective.
"I come now to a critical turn in the argument. For the argument concerns not simply the ontological idea of wealth, however "realistic" we may now see that it is on its own terms, but the bearing of this idea on wealth in its specifically economic context, or on the nature of economic exchanges themselves. This requires that the ontological idea of wealth as a matter primarily of gift and gratitude be shown to carry its own way of producing and exchanging and possessing things. It must be shown that the things produced, exchanged, and possessed will themselves differ in their very character as things, depending on the extent to which their production, exchange, and possession is integrated into a grateful sense of reality as gift - that is, such that the things themselves take on the nature of gift."
Another novum in this remarkable text is the Pope’s insistence that, alongside of the contractual logic of the marketplace (one gives in order to receive) and the legal logic of the political realm (one gives because one is obliged to give), there must be the logic of sheer gratuity (one gives simply because it is good to do so). Without this third element, both the economic and political devolve into something less than fully human.
Fr. Fessio seems to think so:
The inclusiveness of this integration is emphatically and perhaps surprisingly exemplified in paragraph 39. There, the Pope states that the "logic of the market and the logic of the state," i.e., free economic exchange with political oversight and restraint, are not enough to secure human flourishing. There must also be "solidarity in relations between citizens, participation and adherence, actions of gratuitousness" or, as he says in summary, "increasing openness, in a world context, to forms of economic activity marked by quotas of gratuitousness and communion." Pope Benedict insists on a "third economic factor" in addition to the market and the state: gratuitousness.
Fumed by Columcille at 2:45 PM. |
Wednesday, July 15, 2009
New CatholicVote.com Video
Fumed by Columcille at 12:56 PM. |
Tuesday, July 14, 2009
ELVIS came to Ann Arbor, but He won't go to Ave Town
watch the five part series on the truth about Elvis's staged death here:
some people say the following is authoritative evidence of the whole question:
and again at Graceland
He rides Line 15 in Poland everyday.
If you don't believe that, then you need to know that ELVIS was an occult practitioner:
(Elvis recognized the devil's part in his success; Elvis was under the influence of occult spirits. Previous bodyguard reveals that Elvis bragged of occultic power and Elvis stated himself to be a prophet. Elvis was not Christian. Elvis )
Fumed by Casimir Pulaski at 6:55 PM. |
"Wise Woman" Code for Neo-Paganism?

As for her being "Catholic", frankly, the most intense feminist neo-pagans I know have Catholic backgrounds.
- A person believed to be skilled in magic or local customs
Goddesses and Wise Women: The Literature of Feminist Spirituality
A Wise Woman's Guide to Spells, Rituals, and Goddess Love
Magic from Mexico: Folk Magic, Prayers, Spells & Recipes as Taught by the Wise Woman of Guadalupe (Is this what "Wise Latina Woman" means?)
Fumed by Columcille at 9:15 AM. |
Monday, July 13, 2009
Ave Maria School of Law
I've been busy with work and not-work, and one assumes Big T is otherwise engaged, but please tell your family and friends to keep up with all doings Ave. We especially invite informed comments to keep us up to date. And speaking of being up to date, I just received confirmation that the availability of the Vineyards campus on Day One-F(la) is a long-shot. It's just so far from being ready as of, well, today. So that will be a fun story to follow. Is there a Cleary across the street in which they can hold classes for the first month or so? (Answer: No.) Minimal parking, too. We all see the humor in that, right?
Let's see, what else? Sonne seems to be working for a firm in Cali. The class schedule hasn't been made public yet (one wonders if it has even been finalized), but he may be a total no-show in FLA. He only showed up in AA last year when the ABA was visiting. To teach a class on employment ethics. You can't make this stuff up. And he was caught in a three-way make-out session with T$M and the Dean in the downstairs hallway. (You can make that up. I just did!!1!) Sonne seems to have had all his bases covered. One wonders if he had inside info re the very real possibility that the school would have closed had ABA approval for the move not been granted.
Big news in the lawsuit, which I can't tell you. But it goes on.
There is a Monaghan Museum at the AMT piazza (sp?) (get it?), as one of our commenters mentioned. Lots of tiger sculptures. Well, two, as memory serves. Same number as stuffed turkeys at Chez L's. And L would be interested to know that there is a nearby casino in the slums of Immokalee. And Publix is a really good grocery. I heard T$M and Barron Collier are covering their losses for the first few years. Condoms are available behind the counter, but one has to request them. I actually consider this a win. They compromised to us, for a change. The Oratory isn't horrible. The sanctuary is unfinished. How they choose to complete it will determine whether it's lame or rather neat. (Has anyone seen the previews for that creepy little kid movie? Is that Thorncrown she firestarters?) The outside of the Oratory is weird, though. I hope they finish the outbuilding-type buildings in stone.
Okay, a little more. AMT is huge, but not at all built up. Which makes the small developments seem smaller and isolated. And I saved a turtle there. Does that make me an American hero? Well, "hero" is your word, but yes. And thank you.
Fumed by Boko Fittleworth at 9:56 PM. |
Sunday, July 12, 2009
CARITAS IN VERITATE
Fumed by Columcille at 6:04 PM. |
Saturday, July 11, 2009
Now the Ministerial Abstention motion makes sense
You've seen my posts -- there is no reconcilliation if we understand them to mean the Catholic Church, that is, the one with the successor of Peter. No, that doesn't make sense, but that's when it hit me, Ad maijorem Monaghani gloriam!
They don't mean that Catholic Church!!!!! They mean the version Tom and Bernie created that reconciles utility under the pro life cover. The Church of Tom which is more CATHOLIC than any other Catholic place... In my opinion, it all makes sense. It was at that point that an angel came and delivered a prayer card with these words:
+TNB+
(AMMG!)
The Founder's Creed
I believe in Tom, the Founder Almighty, creator of the schools and the town,
and of all party lines, written or unwritten.
I believe in one brand, Ave Maria, the only begotten brand of Tom. begotten of Tom before all other so-called catholic places. Orthodox of orthodoxy, conservative of conservatives, very brand of catholic brands, of one substance with the Founder, by Whom all we say is determined.
Who, for us peons and our salvation, came down from his Lions sky box and was incardinated in Southeast Michigan, and was made in glossy print; and was crucified for us by the liberal press and the other people who aren't true believers, like the terrorists and democrats; He recapitulated, saw a profit in Florida, removed his area impact study in order to be denied planning; in the third year He rose the plans again in Florida, according to the agenda he set in 2001; he ascended into Naples and sits sits at the right hand of Patron Collier but in the town of Marco; He will come again and again with PR and attorneys to judge the peons, the terrorists, and the naysayers.
And I believe in his PR Machine, the word and destroyer of adverse facts; who proceeds from the Founder and the Brand; who with the Founder and the Brand is to be blindly adhered; and is spoken by the now favored ones.
And I believe in one, unified, universal, and violently defended party line. I acknowledge one chance to be on the Founder's good side; and I look for a mortgage free property in the town, as well as a chance to vote. Amen.
On the back side is an unrecognized picture (sorry, I don't have a camera or scanner), with little children saluting an image of Tom in the sky over the oratory, and this pledge:
I pledge allegiance to the Founder
and the great town and schools he founded
and to his whims
for which we act
one religion
under Tom
with one will and PR message for all.
Fumed by Casimir Pulaski at 10:53 AM. |
Friday, July 10, 2009
National Law Journal on Safranek v. Monaghan
Fumed by Advocatus Militaris at 2:34 PM. |
Thursday, July 02, 2009
Kmiec To Be Named Ambassador To Malta
Wednesday, July 01, 2009
A week without West
It is important to understand, however, that good will is not synonymous with sound thought; and I must say, not without reluctance, that West’s work seems to me to misrepresent in significant ways the thought of John Paul II.
click here to see full article.
BUT WAIT! There's more! Idiot lawyer Chris Ferrara, who has some precision but no accuracy, lucked into a grouping pretty close to the mark in his latest attempt to fire some rounds-- published in today's Remnant click here
Typical of his style, he front-loads his bias in conclusive transitions (and over uses the magical word "clearly") but this quote is worth mention:
I rather doubt that theological truths of momentous importance for the Church and the world were left unspoken for nearly 2,000 years, only to emerge suddenly in “John Paul’s thought” by way of little-known addresses so “dense” they need to be “translated” by “secondary literature.” Yet the lay “translators” of TOB preposterously “interpret” a series of opaque commentaries as nothing less than the hope of the world in our time, the implication being—and this is classic neo-Catholicism—that the Church’s teaching on marriage and procreation before Vatican II was all pretty much worthless.
Schindler's crtique is worth the read. Ferrara makes a good point in criticizing the "holy sex" exhuberance.
So let's see if the West fans and TOB Luddites can overcome their prediliction to write off crticism as warrantless because it comes from traditionalists (an inherent fallacy of ad hominem) and properly respond to Schindler (Smith's attempt was laughably flat) or Ferrara (who is a trad, but lucked into some ok points). I don't think they can do it. They rely on emoting, while what I'm asking for takes reason.
Fumed by Casimir Pulaski at 5:20 PM. |
© 2007 FUMARE





